Table of Contents Toggle My sister-in-law made this once and I couldn’t stop eating itI first discovered in a church cookbook years ago and there was no turning back after that! I double the recipe and it’s still the first thing cleaned outTotal hit recipe for my daughters pool party! I’ll definitely be making it again this summerOld-Fashioned Custard PieMade these for Christmas Eve dinner and they were a big hit. Even my 3 yr old Granddaughter ate them and asked for moreAmish Pasta Salad My sister-in-law made this once and I couldn’t stop eating it Elizabeth M. — May 15, 2025 I first discovered in a church cookbook years ago and there was no turning back after that! I double the recipe and it’s still the first thing cleaned out Elizabeth M. — May 15, 2025 Total hit recipe for my daughters pool party! I’ll definitely be making it again this summer Elizabeth M. — May 15, 2025 Old-Fashioned Custard Pie Elizabeth M. — May 15, 2025 Made these for Christmas Eve dinner and they were a big hit. Even my 3 yr old Granddaughter ate them and asked for more Elizabeth M. — May 15, 2025 Amish Pasta Salad Elizabeth M. — May 15, 2025 Previous 1…3940414243…51 Next
